Top Stories[NDPS] Lack Of Independent Witness Not Fatal ; Police Officer’s Testimony Shall Be Scrutinized With Greater Care: Supreme Court [Read Judgment] LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK27 Oct 2020 3:43 AMShare This – xThe Supreme Court has reiterated that, in NDPS cases, lack of independent witnesses are not fatal to the prosecution cases.The bench comprising Justices NV Ramana, Surya Kant and Hrishikesh Roy observed that, in such cases, the Courts have to adopt a greater degree of care while scrutinising the testimonies of the police officers. If they are found reliable, they can form the basis of…Your free access to Live Law has expiredTo read the article, get a premium account.Your Subscription Supports Independent JournalismSubscription starts from ₹ 599+GST (For 6 Months)View PlansPremium account gives you:Unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments.Reading experience of Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.Subscribe NowAlready a subscriber?LoginThe Supreme Court has reiterated that, in NDPS cases, lack of independent witnesses are not fatal to the prosecution cases.The bench comprising Justices NV Ramana, Surya Kant and Hrishikesh Roy observed that, in such cases, the Courts have to adopt a greater degree of care while scrutinising the testimonies of the police officers. If they are found reliable, they can form the basis of a successful conviction, the bench observed.In this case, the Trial Court while acquitting the accused, held that no independent witness supported the prosecution case and that the testimonies of the star police witnesses were contradictory. In this case, one independent witness had turned hostile. The High Court, while reversing the acquittal, had noted that the contradictions are trivial and that the hostile witness’ testimony supported the prosecution case. Agreeing with the findings of the High Court, the bench observed.”It would be gainsaid that lack of independent witnesses are not fatal to the prosecution case. However, such omissions cast an added duty on Courts to adopt a greater degree of care while scrutinising the testimonies of the police officers, which if found reliable can form the basis of a successful conviction.” The accused also contended that the contents of the reply filed by prosecution to his bail plea proved that the case was not of chance recovery. In this regard, the bench observed that there is a distinction between ‘replies’ submitted to the Court in some pending proceedings, as compared to the statements recorded by the police under Section 161 of CrPC. It said:Nevertheless, a Court should be overcautious to place reliance on a piece of evidence with which the concerned witness has not been confronted despite an opportunity to do so. Although there is no need to separately prove the court records emanating during trial but no legal presumption can be extended to the veracity of the contents of such documents. The reply filed in court proceedings, at best, can be treated as an admission; which as held by this Court in Sita Ram Bhau Patil v. Ramchandra Nago Patil5 , must not only be proved, but also the opposite party must be confronted with it at the stage of cross examination. Though it did not interfere in the sentence imposed, the bench noted a recent judgment in Hira Singh v. Union of India which held that the total quantity of the mixture, which includes the neutral substance, ought to be relevant for purposes of sentencing. “This total quantity in the instant case is 1 kg 230 gms, which exceeds the definition of ‘commercial quantity’ as specified at Sl. No. 23 in Notification S.O. 1055 (E), dated 19.10.2001. Thus, the sentence accorded by the High Court is clearly already far too charitable.”, the court added.Case: Raveen Kumar vs. State of Himachal Pradesh [ CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS. 218788 of 2011]Coram: Justices NV Ramana, Surya Kant and Hrishikesh Roy Click here to Read/Download JudgmentRead JudgmentNext Story
Romelu Lukaku inspired Everton to a stunning fightback at West Brom as the Toffees recovered from 2-0 down to win 3-2. Mori had enjoyed a untroubled half but imploded when he lost the ball near the halfway line after trying to run out of defence. It found Morrison and his excellent throughball for Berahino saw the striker slip in a low shot via Tim Howard’s leg. It was the striker’s second goal since returning to the starting line-up following his deadline day strike threat and underlined why the Baggies were so determined to keep him away from Tottenham. Buoyed, James McClean fired over immediately after the restart and Mori escaped a penalty shout after pushing over Salomon Rondon. Darren Fletcher then had a header turned needlessly wide by Howard after 54 minutes and Albion doubled their lead from the resulting corner. Phil Jagielka and Barkley got themselves in a mess trying to pick up Dawson and Jonny Evans which allowed Dawson to nod in Chris Brunt’s deep delivery. Instantly, though, Everton hit back when Lukaku headed Deulofeu’s cross past Boaz Myhill. With that the game turned even if Everton’s desperation was growing and James McCarthy was booked for an awful dive in the box with 20 minutes left. Yet Kone levelled four minutes later – and just three minutes after coming on. Again, Lukaku did brilliantly on the edge of the box to spot Kone’s run and threaded the ball through to the former Wigan forward, who was just onside, to drill past Myhill. The Baggies were shellshocked and former Chelsea striker Lukaku was not finished as he wrapped up Everton’s comeback with six minutes left. There was a hint of handball when he met Deulofeu’s cross by splitting Dawson and James Chester but with Myhill slow to react Lukaku smashed in from close range to win it. TWEET OF THE MATCH “@TonyBellew: Romelu Lukaku take a bow!! #EFC” – Boxer and Everton fan Tony Bellew was impressed with Lukaku’s performance. RATINGS West Brom: Boaz Myhill: 6 (out of 10) Craig Dawson: 7 Jonny Evans: 6 Jonas Olsson: 6 Chris Brunt: 6 Claudio Yacob: 6 James McClean: 6 James Morrison: 7 Darren Fletcher: 7 Saido Berahino: 7 Salomon Rondon: 6 Subs: James Chester: 6 Craig Gardner: 6 Rickie Lambert: 6 Everton: Tim Howard: 6 Tyias Browning: 7 Phil Jagielka: 6 Ramiro Funes Mori: 5 Brendan Galloway: 6 Gareth Barry: 6 James McCarthy: 6 Steven Naismith: 7 Ross Barkley: 6 Gerard Deulofeu: 8 Romelu Lukaku: 8 Subs: Darron Gibson: 6 Arouna Kone: 7 Aaron Lennon: 6 STAR MAN: Romelu Lukaku The striker inspired Everton to a comeback which few saw coming during a poor first 55 minutes at The Hawthorns. The visitors struggled to spark in the first half and looked dead and buried after Craig Dawson made it 2-0. But Lukaku, against his former loan club, showed his class to make it six goals for the season and rescue the visitors. His assist for Arouna Kone’s equaliser showed brilliant vision and he was deadly in front of goal when it mattered. MOMENT OF THE MATCH: Few could have predicted the late drama following a first half which lacked tempo until Saido Berahino’s opener. But Lukaku proved the difference between the sides when he slammed in the winner with just six minutes left, to complete Everton’s comeback. He had already produced a fine header to pull a goal back and then a cute pass to set up Kone’s equaliser on 75 minutes. West Brom will be disappointed at the nature of the goal, with Boaz Myhill perhaps too slow to react, but the Toffees will not care one bit. MOAN OF THE MATCH: Tony Pulis will be wondering how West Brom blew their 2-0 lead to leave them winless at home in the Barclays Premier League this season. The Baggies looked on course for a comfortable win after Berahino and Craig Dawson had put the hosts in charge. Albion’s usually reliable defence faltered under the threat of Lukaku in the second half, while previously they had kept 14 clean sheets in 24 league games. VIEW FROM THE BENCH: Roberto Martinez was staring defeat in the face when his Everton side fell 2-0 behind before their remarkable comeback. Kone scored just over three minutes after coming on as the Toffees changes made a late difference. But Martinez can rely on Lukaku to make the difference as the striker showed his manager what he is capable of. The Baggies had struggled for goals this season, scoring just four prior to this game, and Tony Pulis will be furious they squandered a comfortable lead. WHO’S UP NEXT Crystal Palace v West Brom (Premier League, Saturday October 3) Everton v Liverpool (Premier League, Sunday October 4) Everton manager Roberto Martinez told Sky Sports: “[We showed] incredible character to come back and get a win. “We had to show a lot of character, a lot of desire, to improve. The first-half performance wasn’t anywhere near our level. [But] we never gave up and we found a way to get back into it. “To score three goals in open play against West Brom speaks volumes of the quality of our play in the second half. “We’ve got a very good squad, we’ve got really good options. [Substitute and goalscorer] Arouna Kone brought a different problem straight away and we took advantage of that confusion.” His West Brom counterpart Tony Pulis added: “We get the second goal and all we have to do is sit tight and be nice and solid for 10 minutes and the game would settle down again. Unfortunately we then give a soft goal [away]. “I think the second goal is offside, I don’t know what the linesman’s doing stooping down and looking inside [Chris] Brunt. He should be stooping down and looking outside Brunt. I’d like to know what he was up to then. “The defending of set plays was awful. We were still celebrating. You have to take the sting out of the game and we didn’t do that. “It’s really, really disappointing because we had the game in our hands and we’ve given it to Everton.” The 22-year-old scored 17 goals during an impressive loan spell at Albion from Chelsea in 2012-13 and ignited Everton’s challenge with Kone’s impact also crucial, the forward scoring within three minutes of coming on as a second-half substitute. It was the first time Everton had come back to win a game in the Barclays Premier League since May 1994 – when they beat Wimbledon 3-2 to stay in the top flight. There was little hint of the drama to come, which left Albion winless at home in the Premier League this season, during a wretched and instantly forgettable first half which was only lit up by Berahino’s opener. Without the sidelined John Stones, out with a knee injury, Ramiro Funes Mori stepped in for his full league debut but the Everton defender was at fault for Albion’s first goal after a dull first 25 minutes. Only the visitors created a clear cut chance before the hosts struck when Ross Barkley blew his lines from eight yards after 29 minutes. The England midfielder started the move with a neat dummy before the ball was worked to Gerard Deulofeu on the right. His fine low pass dissected the Albion defence only for an on-rushing Barkley to wretchedly miscue his shot wide. It was a horrible miss and one which the Toffees would pay for when the Baggies opened the scoring four minutes before the break. Press Association The former Baggies striker scored twice and set up Arouna Kone as the visitors scored twice in the final 15 minutes to steal the points. Saido Berahino and Craig Dawson had put the Baggies 2-0 ahead but Lukaku hit back immediately after Dawson’s header nine minutes after the break.
Nick Evans has targeted a top-four finish for Harlequins this season.The fly-half’s flawless kicking helped his team to a 29-24 victory over London Irish in Saturday’s Premiership opener at Twickenham.Morale in the Quins camp is high after last season’s Amlin Challenge Cup success and Evans declared: “Top four, that’s where we want to get to – that’s our ambition.AdChoices广告“We’ve got a taste for winning trophies now, but we’re not going to come out saying we’re going to win this and that, so top four is what we’re aiming for.“I came over here to win trophies, with a young squad when I arrived. But you can throw that away now – we’re not a young squad anymore. We’ve been together for three years, so maybe some are young in age but not experience.“We’ve played in finals, gone to Munster and things like that. Trophies are what we’re here for and I enjoy rugby when we’re winning.”Quins’ winning start to their campaign was somewhat marred by a sickening injury to the unfortunate Tom Guest.The stand-in number 8, who spent most of last season out of action, had his arm broken in two places in a collision with Chris Hala’ufia.